From Miami Experts to Your Inbox
Only the top restaurants, promos, and specials, hand selected by Miami foodies.
Categories: Dish Kitch

Two-Ingredient Peanut Butter Cups Recipe

As you may or may not know, The first Peanut Butter Cup,was created in 1928 by The H.B. Reese Candy Company. It was first called “Penny Cups” because they only cost one cent at that time! H.B. Reese had a hard time getting a candy company off the ground. After five whole years in his basement, the Reese’s cups were created and his candy company got off the ground. Interestingly enough, Reese was attempting to help a commercial customer who wasn’t getting his supply of chocolate covered peanut butter candies fast enough and needed Reese to fill the order faster. It was important to Reese that he used quality ingredients so he used Hershey’s chocolate and high-quality peanut butter. It was also said that he used a secret ingredient or two (sounds legit). This was Reese’s third attempt at creating a successful candy company and I am sure he is glad he kept trying, as our we. The peanut butter cup in this recipe and in many recipes all over the world, resembles the first peanut butter cup from 1928. History tastes great, doesn’t it?

Combining chocolate with peanut butter is no secret, even if these candies were created in 1928, the practice of combining the two ingredients had been done years before. With good reason too, the saltiness of peanut butter combines with the sweetness of chocolate creates a common “sweet and salty” snack that everyone can enjoy. But not too sweet, not too salty, just right. 

AuthorDish MiamiCategoryDesserts

7 oz melted dark unsweetened chocolate
½ cup smooth or chunky peanut butter

1

Arrange a muffin tin with muffin cups and coat them with melted dark and unsweetened chocolate.

2

Add dollops of the peanut butter and cover with the rest of the chocolate.

3

Let them chill in the fridge for about 20-25 minutes.

4

Peel the muffin cups and serve right away or keep them in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

Ingredients

7 oz melted dark unsweetened chocolate
½ cup smooth or chunky peanut butter

Directions

1

Arrange a muffin tin with muffin cups and coat them with melted dark and unsweetened chocolate.

2

Add dollops of the peanut butter and cover with the rest of the chocolate.

3

Let them chill in the fridge for about 20-25 minutes.

4

Peel the muffin cups and serve right away or keep them in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

Notes

Peanut Butter Cups Recipe
Share
Published by

Recent Posts

The Best New Restaurants in Miami [May 2025]

Miami’s dining scene never sleeps—and thank goodness for that. Just when you think you’ve tried…

9 hours ago

Where to Take Your Business Clients in Miami

In a city like Miami, the right restaurant can set the tone for everything—whether you're…

1 day ago

What to Do in Miami This Week [Apr 28-May 5]

Welcome to our weekly roundup! Stay up-to-date on the hottest events and trends in Miami…

3 days ago

The Best Sushi in Wynwood

From sleek and modern interiors to the freshest ocean offerings meticulously crafted by skilled sushi…

7 days ago

6 Miami Hot Spots with Large Wine Selections

For some restaurants, wine selections are an afterthought. For others, wine is just as important…

1 week ago

The Best Italian Restaurants in Brickell

From rustic pizza parlors to restaurants where you can find hand-rolled pasta, Brickell has some…

1 week ago

This site uses cookies.

Privacy Policy