fbpx
Best Italian restaurants in Miami
Osteria Del Teatro

The Best Italian Restaurants in Miami

You don’t have to travel to Italy to try some of the best food the Mediterranean-side country has to offer, from Lombardy and down to Sicily. Luckily, Miami has some of the world’s top acclaimed Italian restaurants. So you can savor everything from saucy and comforting nonna’s spaghetti and meatballs to next level prosciutto. There are tons to feast on, and the city’s Italian restaurants work hard to compete within the fast-paced industry. We’ve helped gather the best Italian restaurants in Miami to make the choice a little easier when craving some decadent hand-cut pasta or a dessert of tiramisu with espresso. 

Amare

Best Italian Restaurants in Miami

The Iovino family has been in the business for over 30 years. The family treats Amare like their home—every dish is prepared from scratch with carefully selected ingredients. This is not the kind of place you’d want to come to on a 30-minute lunch break, but it’s definitely the spot to recline and savor a full experience with some good company. And if the weather is right, the charming courtyard is the way to go.

Though you may have a tough time navigating their extensive menu, the attentive staff will help you choose the right dish and wine to pair with it. And honestly, you can’t go wrong here. Each dish is prepared to highlight the ingredients used, a culinary practice seen less and less nowadays. 

Giving a little taste of what to expect — Fior Di Zucca El Baccala (zucchini blossoms stuffed with a mind-blowing concoction of creamy Atlantic cod and robiola cheese); Linguine Alle Vongole, a clean performance of the classic little neck clam pasta sure to tickle any seafood lover’s fancy. On the other hand, the Carpaccio Amare, made with Filet Mignon, artichokes, asparagus, shaved Parmigiano, and truffle salt, might change your interpretation of “best carpaccio” for good.

1 Collins Avenue, Miami Beach, FL; (305) 731-6999, amareristorante.com; Open Sun -Thurs noon-3 p.m. and 6-11 p.m.; Friday-Saturday noon-3 p.m. and 6 p.m.-12 a.m.

Osteria Del Teatro

Osteria Del Teatro has held the title of “Miami Beach Best Italian Restaurant” time and time again. And with over 30 years in the business, everyone from celebrities to out-of-town guests have come to rate this classy spot. The interior of the old Marlin hotel, where it’s located, is simply stunning. During lunch, the big windows provide plenty of sunlight and opportunity for people-watching. For dinner, you’ll find more of a dimly-lit date kind of vibe. 

The cuisine showcases the best of North Italian fare. Pasta is hand-made daily. So is the compelling complimentary bread. But what’s to come requires full attention and an empty stomach, so take it easy!

Start off with the Fotomodella (Prosciutto di Parma nestled with imported Buffalo mozzarella and homemade roasted peppers with basil, capers, and anchovies). If you’re lucky, you’ll catch the Pappardelle con Astice (Whole Maine lobster with homemade pappardelle in a creamy pink lobster sauce) off the specials menu. It’s to die for. 

Those looking for fewer carbs and more substance have a wide choice from ethically raised meat and fish. And by all means – please save room for dessert. The restaurant’s proclaimed “best Tiramisu in North America” is a treat not to be missed. As for wine, though the menu might seem intimidating at first, the staff will help you pair-up for the most bubbly of evenings.

1200 Collins Avenue, Miami Beach, FL;(305) 538-7850, osteriadelteatro.miami; Open Thurs-Sun, 5 -9:30 p.m.

Riviera Focacceria Italiana

Come to Riviera Focacceria to sample pure genius executed by age-old Ligurian traditions. Take a step into this humble trattoria, and you’ll see that quality beats pompousness any day. The folks who run this place aren’t here to please the hearts of those looking for the next Instagram sensation but are here to simply let the food speak for itself. Be sure to make a reservation in order to see the magic firsthand. 

While glancing through the menu, you’re sure to notice the trays of perfectly toasted focaccia passing by the hands of sincere waiters. The smell of soft-baked cheese fills the air. Diner’s eyes glistening with anticipation — “I came here hungry. Should I risk jumping the gun, or death by chaffing?” Chances are you’ll have a glass of wine by your side, so take your time and thoroughly enjoy the wait. And yes, as you may have already guessed by the establishment’s name, ordering the Focaccia con Formaggio is a must. 

But let’s stay focused. That’s only for starters. Mains include housemade pasta dishes like Trenette al Pesto (signature Ligurian pasta featuring the restaurant’s revered housemade pesto), Ravioli Ragu Genovese (ravioli filled with spinach, beef, Parmigiano cheese, and Italian herbs in a 6-hour slow-cooked beef, pork, and tomato ragout), and the Polpo alla Griglia (grilled, poached octopus accompanied by the delicate yet piquant melange of chickpea puree, roasted pumpkin seeds, and smoked paprika). Wednesdays feature half off on bottles from Riviera Focacceria’s carefully selected wine collection. We suggest arriving with some good company for this one. 

3252 Buena Vista Blvd #110, Miami, FL 33137; (786) 220-6251; rivierafocacceria.com Open Mon – Thurs, 11:30 a.m.–10:30 p.m.; Fri – Sat 11:30 a.m. –11 p.m.; Sun noon–10:30 p.m.

Sottosale

Best Italian restaurants in Miami

Nowadays, when we hear Sottosale, we know we’re in for a spread of Italian comfort food. Come hungry. Come with company. This is not exactly the place where you’ll be well off ordering a side salad — portions are family-sized. Luckily, this is one of those places where quantity doesn’t mean a sacrifice in quality. The chefs are well aware of what they bring to the table and do it with skill and soul — nothing less of what you’d expect from an Italian nonna. Dishes are unquestionably executed with class and mastery, so don’t expect the sloppy joe presentation of the corner pizzeria. It’s quite a wonder how these heartwarming plates can mingle so well with the top-notch presentation, clad within a laid back and homey atmosphere. 

For starters, let’s bring it back to everyone’s childhood favorite — fried goodness. The restaurant’s signature Fritto Misto is a mish-mash of perfectly crispy, not too oily, calamari, shrimp, smelts, and veggies. As for pasta, the Rigatoncini Allo Stracotto certainly captured our hearts. Al dente rigatoni meshes ideally with pulled overnight-cooked lamb shank and shaved Ricotta Salata. That’s the kind of care your family puts into a meal, all at the hands of chef Ivo. And of course, pizza… Can’t go wrong with any of them. Thin crust, puffed and toasty edges, layered with a plethora of ingredients that already stand out on their own. Now place them on the pizza… It gets no better. Expect speck, marinated boquerones, artichokes, and fresh mozz, to name a few.

What really makes this Italian kitchen stand out in Miami’s bustling food scene is the sincerity with which they operate. The restaurant’s very own enoteca offers wine at retail price plus a $10 corkage fee (Wednesdays are corkage fee-free). Also, don’t miss the November special for BOGO bottles of wine. By the way, there are specials to take advantage of daily, so you’ll be winning any day of the week. 

8001 Biscayne Blvd, Miami, FL 33138; (786) 634-1005;  sottosalemiami.com; Open Tue-Fri, 5-11p.m.; Sat and Sun, noon-11p.m.

Toscana Divino

Toscana Divino falls off the tongue of any Miamian enticed by luxury dining. It’s not easy to combine next-level sustainability practices with superior cuisine. Yet, this Italian kitchen sets the mark high for anyone willing to follow in their footsteps. Since opening its doors in 2012, the restaurant has been annually named top three Italian cuisines in Miami — that’s nearly a decade of offering the city exceptional food and service!

This Brickell restaurant pays homage to the exuberant cuisine of Tuscany. Upon entering, you’ll immediately notice the monumental collection of wine, much of which comes from the Tuscany region itself. Diners have the option of enjoying their meal in the sleek interior, taking advantage of the open kitchen where executive chef Andrea Marchesin showcases his skill. Otherwise, one can opt for the casual yet spacious outdoor seating, soaking in the city’s tempo. 

The restaurant’s main principles are sustainability and seasonality. A seasonally-rotating menu comes to no surprise and only entices patrons to dine here more frequently to savor the peak of each ingredient. This year’s fall-winter menu features appetizers of poached lobster and peppers, as well as octopus puttanesca. A concise collection of pasta and risotto, including the luscious Carbonara Di Mare, an exceptionally executed spaghetti chitarra, pearled with sea urchin, fish roes, caviar, and bottarga. For seconds, an autumn rendition of Filet Mignon is served with pumpkin and chanterelle mushrooms. And if you thought the best burrata is always imported from Italy, think again. Toscana Divino serves the creamiest, most delicate local Burrata Caprese — naturally, all complemented by Tuscany’s robust wines. 

900 S Miami Ave, Miami, FL 33130; (305) 371-2767; toscanadivino.com; Open Mon – Fri, noon-10 p.m.; Sat, 5-10 p.m.

Palat

Palat is a fairly new edition to Miami’s highly competitive food scene. Albeit in the past two years of its existence, it has quickly earned the hearts of hungry Miamians looking for a fashionable Italian seafood feast. The minimalist interior encompasses an open kitchen and a shared indoor/outdoor dining space. Large wooden dining tables and industrial lighting creates a chic air suitable for nights out on the town, dates, and celebrations. 

Fresh seafood is the name of the game here, and plates at Palat yearn for sharing. The menu is compact and well-curated, which means you’ll get to try an abundance of dishes if you choose to come with a crowd. For example, the choice of grilled octopus or calamari. Or better yet, both. Main dishes encompass the zesty salmon steak served with a refreshing citrus-ginger creme; and Gamberoni All Griglia, scandalous seared head-on prawns. The star of the show, however, might just be the Tagliolini “Cacio e Pepe” a timeless classic of creamy tagliolini pasta with an exclusive twist of shaved black truffle served in a wheel of Parmigiano cheese. Pair with one of Palat’s many organic wine options for the complete celebration for the senses. 

4702 NE 2nd Ave, Miami, FL 33137; 786-953-7577, palatmiami.com; Open Sun-Wed, noon-10 p.m.; Fri-Sat noon-11 p.m.

Photo credit: Ruben Cabrera

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the dish on culinary, travel, and wellness in Miami

By clicking sign up you’re agreeing to our terms of service and privacy policy.

Photo credit: Ruben Cabrera

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the dish on culinary, travel, and wellness in Miami